Escape to RealityRanking the best reality & competition shows and exploring the attention-starved monsters we create and feed when we watch them participate.
Vote up the most-liked people from 'Temptation Island.'
Who do you think is the most popular Temptation Island cast member? Throughout the series, contestants - like Kate Griffith - experience betrayal, a host of wild drama, temptation, of course, but also personal growth.
Griffith went through a lot on season 5 of Temptation Island, as her boyfriend at the time, David Benavidez, went on to become involved with multiple women during the show. There were also several big confrontations between them, thanks to Benavidez's wandering eye. Kaci Campbell is another popular cast member from Temptation Island. She, too, felt the sting of betrayal when her boyfriend at the time, Evan Smith, decided to pursue a single on the island, Morgan Lolar. Campbell ended up leaving on her own, and later found happiness with someone else. Casey Starchak of season 2 is one of the men who changed his behavior on the island after realizing what he would lose if he broke up with girlfriend Ashley Howland. They ended up leaving the island together.
Read more about the Temptation Island stars below, and be sure to vote up the ones you find most likable.
Kate Griffith participated in season 5 of Temptation Island along with her then-boyfriend David Benavidez. Kate struggled throughout the season as she watched David become involved with multiple women on the island, leading to several emotional confrontations between them during bonfire ceremonies. Kate's resilience and strength resonated with viewers, as she navigated through this challenging experience.
Ashley Howland was another memorable participant who appeared in season 2, alongside her then-boyfriend Casey Starchak. Ashley became known for her emotional vulnerability and growth throughout the season, as she navigated through various temptations. She ultimately decided to stay with Casey at the end of their journey; however, they later revealed that they had broken up after returning home from filming.
Kaci Campbell is one of the most popular figures from Temptation Island, appearing in season 1. Kaci and her boyfriend Evan Smith came to the island to test their relationship, but things took a turn when Evan fell for another woman, Morgan Lolar. Kaci's emotional journey on the show, and her genuine reactions made her a fan favorite. Despite the heartbreak she experienced on the show, she has since moved on and found happiness with someone else.
7 votes
Photo: Temptation Island / USA
4
5 VOTES
Erica Washington
Erica Washington was another memorable cast member from season 3 who came into Temptation Island alongside her boyfriend Kendal Kirkland. Throughout her journey on the show, Erica faced numerous challenges as she learned about Kendal's actions on the island, while trying to remain true to herself and grow emotionally stronger amidst temptation. Her ability to maintain grace under pressure and her personal growth made her a fan favorite.
Morgan Lolar made a significant impact on Temptation Island during season 1. As a single, she quickly caught the attention of Evan Smith, who was in a relationship with Kaci Campbell at the time. Morgan's connection with Evan led to one of the most dramatic moments in the show's history, when he chose to leave Kaci for her. The couple got engaged after leaving the island, but eventually ended their relationship amid cheating allegations.
Kendal Kirkland made waves during his appearance on season 3 of Temptation Island alongside his girlfriend Erica Washington. Kendal was known for pushing boundaries within their relationship by engaging intimately with multiple singles on the island. His actions caused tension and heartbreak for Erica, but also sparked conversations among viewers about trust and respect within relationships.
